Miami Dolphins coach Mike McDaniel learned WRONG lesson from Heat coach Erik Spoelstra

Miami Dolphins head coach Mike McDaniel is undoubtedly an offensive genius. His scheme is so intricate and so highly detailed that when it’s working the way it’s supposed to, it can seldom be stopped. However, there is a problem. The scheme he runs demands high level talent. It demands elite level execution. And for all the effort being put into player development, the reality is that players cannot be rotated in and out at random.

The past two seasons, a big deal was made about Mike McDaniel spending time with longtime Miami Heat coach Erik Spoelstra. What lessons he must be learning, what words of wisdom McDaniel was taking from a multiple championship winning coach who knows what it takes to win. Through that, McDaniel began to create a culture that players want to be a part of, and it eventually led to owner Stephen Ross giving him an extension through 2028.

But all of the lessons he learned from Spoelstra, it seems the one he took to heart to most is the one that makes no sense in the game of football. The concept of load management.

In the NBA, there are 82 games in the regular season, and that number grows if you make the playoffs. Games are played one to two days apart from each other, and so sitting star veterans makes sense in a league that demands so much play time from their players. Spoelstra has taken criticism at times for his approach, but for the most part it’s a smart strategy. Why play your best players if they aren’t needed or need to rest an injury? There will be another game in a couple days.

However, in the NFL, there is no such luxury. There are only 17 games in the season, and the number of teams that actually make the playoffs is much smaller. Even worse, playoff teams get no room for error in the NFL. If you lose once, you are eliminated. There is no time to regroup and try again.

Back at the beginning of the 2023 season, McDaniel spoke on what he’d learned from Spoelstra.

“I use basketball references all the time.” He said. “I think watching the Heat play gave me all sorts of motivation in the offseason, just by team over everything. What is the saying? The sum is greater than the parts, or whatever? That’s what I see from them, and I think that very much applies to professional football in general, because you always have talented players across the board, but 11 people working together is what generates results.”

That last part is true, it takes all 11 players doing their job to make an offense or a defense run. But the idea of the sum being greater than the parts? In the NFL, that is just not true. The parts matter a lot more than the sum they make.

Really good football teams have their best players on the field a majority of the time. The Philadelphia Eagles, for example, have A.J. Brown and Devonta Smith (whom the Miami Dolphins opted not to draft in favor of Jaylen Waddle). Within the first two weeks, Smith has played – quite literally – every single snap on offense. 100% of them. A.J. Brown, an older veteran, played 95% of the snaps in Week 1 before suffering an injury in Week 2 that kept him out entirely.

The list of wide receivers continues.

For the Cincinnati Bengals, Ja’Marr Chase played 84% and 92% of the snaps.

For the Baltimore Ravens, Zay Flowers played 89% of the snaps in both Weeks 1 and 2, while Rashod Bateman played 84% and 82%.

For the Kansas City Chiefs, Rashee Rice played “only” 78% and 83% of the snaps. But at tight end, veteran Travis Kelce played 89% and 91% of the snaps as their top weapon.

Contrast that with the Miami Dolphins, who have Jaylen Waddle and the players-voted best player in the NFL: Tyreek Hill. The difference is staggering.

In Weeks 1 and 2, Waddle played 72% of the snaps. That in and of itself is bad enough.

Tyreek Hill, the $30+ per year wide receiver, the best player in the league according to his peers, played 70% and 68% of the snaps in Weeks 1 and 2.

Why are the team’s top weapons spending so much time watching from the sidelines, letting players like the newly added Grant DuBose or the recently released Robbie Chosen take so many crucial snaps in important situations? How does one justify that?

Now, Tua Tagovailoa is on injured reserve with another concussion, and won’t return until at least Week 8 against the Arizona Cardinals. This means, Skylar Thompson is being counted on to keep the season afloat. Needless to say, there’s a significant gap between Thompson and Tagovailoa.

Mike McDaniel has an opportunity now to make a necessary adjustment. If the Dolphins are going to win any of the next four games, they need to lean on their best players. Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle need to be on the field for every important snap the offense has. Defenses respect their presence, and laugh when the likes of Braxton Berrios and Grant DuBose show up.

It’s time to have the best players play, and move on from the load management idea. Rotations work a lot better in basketball than football. Mike McDaniel needs to let his playmakers make plays. Only then will they find themselves winning games consistently.

******

For all your daily fantasy sports content, use the code FIVE at PrizePicks.com