Mike McDaniel’s Bizarre Loyalty to Skylar Thompson

In the ever-evolving saga of the Miami Dolphins’ backup quarterback conundrum, head coach Mike McDaniel’s latest decision has left fans scratching their heads Sunday’s game provided a fresh chapter in what’s becoming a saga of loyalty over logic, where Skylar Thompson, not for the first time, was given the nod in a critical game scenario that could have warranted a different choice.

The Dolphins parted ways with Mike White before the season started, leaving their backup quarterback depth chart in disarray, bringing in zero new faces. With Tua Tagovailoa on IR, Thompson was called upon to step up. However, his performance last Thursday, and his start on Sunday weren’t just underwhelming—they were outright ineffectual. He couldn’t even orchestrate a single competent offensive drive. Yet, after the game, McDaniel said, “I did think Skylar did a good job operating the offense,” before shifting blame to himself for the team’s lack of preparation. While taking accountability is commendable, this response seemed to downplay Thompson’s inability to move the chains and put points on the board, suggesting a level of satisfaction that felt disconnected from reality.

The perplexing issue isn’t just the in-game decision but the broader strategy. Despite having Tyler Huntley as better alternative, albeit still learning the system, McDaniel’s unwavering faith in Thompson—a quarterback who has had ample opportunity to prove himself and failed to do so—raises eyebrows. Even more confounding is McDaniel’s refusal to rule out Thompson as a potential starter for the next game, despite his disastrous performance.

The Dolphins, a team in “win-now mode,” cannot afford to be sentimental with their quarterback choices. Every game is too valuable to be used as a development platform for someone who hasn’t shown the necessary growth. McDaniel’s continued reliance on Thompson, even as a backup, might reflect a commitment to loyalty over strategic prudence. His comments suggest an almost stubborn attachment to the idea of Thompson succeeding, even when the results consistently indicate otherwise.

This scenario is not an isolated incident. It’s part of a pattern where McDaniel has consistently supported Thompson, even when other quarterbacks could potentially offer a different dynamic or a higher performance ceiling. While loyalty is admirable, it risks hindering the team if not balanced with the realities of NFL competition. McDaniel and even GM Chris Grier’s reluctance to explore options further complicates the picture. It’s as if he’s holding on to a project that’s already failed to deliver.

While McDaniel’s faith in Thompson may be less about what he can achieve on the field and more about what he symbolizes: hard work and dedication, in professional sports, where every decision can sway the balance of victory or defeat, such sentiments, while noble, often come at a steep price.

The controversy surrounding McDaniel’s quarterback decisions goes beyond just Sunday’s game; it reflects on the Dolphins’ strategic direction. The fact that Miami brought in Boyle and Huntley—both still learning the system—underscores the lack of depth at the position, making Thompson’s continued role as the backup even more puzzling. If McDaniel’s loyalty to Thompson continues to dictate the quarterback rotation, it may be time for fans and analysts to question if this approach aligns with the “win-now” mentality. The saga of Skylar Thompson under McDaniel’s guidance could define this era of the Dolphins, for better or, as it increasingly appears, for worse.

Follow @FinsDynasty and @5ReasonsSports on Instagram