The Dolphins Need a Backup Plan, and They Need It Now

Last night was a gut-wrenching loss for the Miami Dolphins, as they fell once again to their division rival Buffalo Bills, this time under the national spotlight of primetime. To make matters worse, the game wasn’t even close. The real heartbreak, however, came when Tua Tagovailoa suffered yet another concussion, casting serious doubt over his future in the NFL. While Tua’s health and well-being are the utmost priority, the Dolphins must prepare for the worst-case scenario — if Tua decides to hang up his cleats, the team needs a backup plan, and it needs one fast.

Miami is in win-now mode. Skylar Thompson, the current backup, hasn’t shown enough to be the solution. The Dolphins cannot afford to let a tragic Week 2 game derail their entire season. They need to address the question looming over the franchise: What happens if Tua can’t return? The answer needs to be found now.

While the options are limited this late in the season, here’s a breakdown of potential quarterback replacements for Miami in this worst-case scenario:

Ryan Tannehill

Familiar Face, Familiar Fit

Tannehill knows Miami like the back of his hand. Having previously played for the Dolphins, his familiarity with the city and the organization means minimal adjustment time. While he’s not at the peak of his career, Tannehill could provide the stability Miami needs with his experience in Mike McDaniel’s system. He may not be the flashiest option, but his ability to manage games could give the Dolphins a fighting chance in a tough AFC race.

Josh Dobbs

Underrated Talent, Intriguing Upside

Dobbs is currently stuck behind other quarterbacks, making him a potential trade target. His mobility and understanding of complex offenses make him an interesting fit for Miami’s dynamic attack. With a strong supporting cast like Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, Dobbs might unlock his full potential. His athleticism would also add a new wrinkle to the Dolphins’ offensive scheme.

Jameis Winston

High-Risk, High-Reward

Currently a backup with the Cleveland Browns, Winston brings a unique combination of experience and playmaking ability. His willingness to push the ball downfield could mesh well with Miami’s offensive weapons, especially with speedsters like Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle on the outside. However, Winston’s turnover issues are well-documented. If Miami is willing to roll the dice, Winston could be an electrifying addition — as long as they can mitigate the risks inherent in his style of play.

Davis Mills

Efficient, Not Exceptional

Mills showed during his time with the Houston Texans that he can manage games. His numbers suggest he’s capable of throwing for over 3,000 yards and a solid number of touchdowns, though his interception rate remains a concern. Still, Mills is young, experienced, and has the tools to be a capable backup. For a team like Miami, in need of a steady hand, Mills could provide a bridge to stability while they figure out the longer-term future at quarterback.

Sam Howell

Potential Future Star

Howell’s college career was filled with highlight-reel plays, and while his NFL journey has been up and down, his raw talent is undeniable. He possesses a strong arm and mobility, two traits that would fit nicely in Miami’s system. Howell is young and could develop into a star with the right coaching and patience. While he’s more of a project, the potential for long-term success makes him an intriguing, albeit risky, option for the Dolphins.