The Dolphins’ Press Conference Was a Masterclass in Excuses and Evasion

Accountability is a rare commodity in the NFL, and in Miami, it seems to be running especially low. In the Dolphins’ season-ending press conference, General Manager Chris Grier and Head Coach Mike McDaniel provided a display that can only be described as an elaborate exercise in finger-pointing, excuse-making, and reality distortion.

This wasn’t your typical postmortem. It was a finely tuned symphony of contradictions, where injuries were simultaneously the cause of every problem and an inevitable aspect of football not worth worrying about in roster construction. It was a surreal performance that left the audience questioning not just the decisions made this season, but the decision-makers themselves.

The Blame Game Begins

When Grier was asked about the team’s shortcomings since their much-publicized salary cap reset, he pointed to the usual suspect: injuries. Specifically, he highlighted Tua Tagovailoa’s six-and-a-half missed games as “the difference.” But almost in the same breath, Grier claimed injuries weren’t an excuse. This verbal gymnastics act—a quick pivot from blame to platitude and back again—was emblematic of the entire presser.

Adding insult to injury (pun intended), Grier dismissed the idea of proactively accounting for injuries in roster building with a flippant comment: “The injury rate in football is 100 percent.” If that’s the case, why does the Dolphins’ depth chart resemble a patchwork quilt held together by hope and duct tape every December?

Offensive Line or Offensive Excuses?

The Dolphins’ offensive line—a perennial weak spot—was a hot topic, and Grier wasted no time joking about how long it took for someone to bring it up. But humor quickly gave way to deflection. Injuries, once again, took center stage, as Grier rationalized the line’s underperformance.

What he didn’t acknowledge was that much of this mess was foreseeable. Terron Armstead, while an elite talent, has averaged only 11 games a season over his career. Kendall Lamm was coaxed out of semi-retirement to provide depth, and Isaiah Wynn’s injury history was well-documented. Even Austin Jackson, who has struggled to stay on the field, was somehow expected to anchor this group. This isn’t bad luck—it’s bad planning.

Grier’s excuses also had a quantum quality: he both addressed and ignored the offensive line in the offseason, justified his inaction because the offense was statistically strong in 2023, and promised to invest in the line moving forward.

The Backup Quarterback Saga

The backup quarterback position was another area where the excuses flowed freely. Grier insisted the team was justified in rolling with Skylar Thompson, who won the backup job in camp, while also claiming the Dolphins were aggressively pursuing “top-flight” backups but missed out due to financial constraints and compensatory pick considerations.

So which was it? Did they believe in Thompson, or did they know they needed a better option but failed to secure one? The contradictions piled up, leaving fans and media scratching their heads.

McDaniel’s Discipline Dilemma

McDaniel didn’t escape scrutiny either. While he spoke earnestly about improving as a disciplinarian, his words felt undermined by Grier’s suggestion that players need to police themselves. McDaniel’s admission that fines haven’t been enough to curb tardiness felt hollow, particularly when coupled with sarcastic asides about how those same fines worked “on every other team.”

It’s hard to reconcile this with McDaniel’s other statements about the importance of culture. Leadership requires consistency, and in this case, the message seemed muddled at best.

The Accountability Void

At the heart of this press conference was a glaring absence of true accountability. Mistakes were acknowledged in one breath and excused in the next. Injuries were blamed, but roster construction wasn’t at fault. Play-calling was criticized, but McDaniel insisted he was the “best person” to handle it.

And while Grier paid lip service to the idea of end-of-year evaluations, his casual mention of reviewing the medical, strength, and video departments felt like a veiled attempt to spread blame further down the organizational ladder.

A Franchise in Survival Mode

What Dolphins fans wanted—and deserved—was a candid assessment of what went wrong and how it will be fixed. What they got was a clinic in deflection. Grier and McDaniel may be adept at surviving press conferences, but survival isn’t the goal. Playoff wins are.

Until the Dolphins’ leadership shows a willingness to take real accountability and make meaningful changes, it’s hard to imagine this franchise breaking free from its cycle of mediocrity. For now, it seems, the Dolphins are more concerned with dodging blame than delivering results.

********

Use the code FIVE to get $50 to play at PrizePicks.com