Tyler Warren at 13? Why the Dolphins Should Look Elsewhere

Tyler Warren, an uber talented tight end from Penn State has been thrown around as a potential option for the Miami Dolphins. The Dolphins hold the 13th pick in this year’s NFL draft after a disappointing 2024 campaign. Many times, a player of Warren’s caliber could be seen as a no brainer, but I personally don’t believe he is the fit. With all of the holes in Miami’s roster it would be much more productive to select an offensive lineman, or maybe even a safety. The draft is after free agency which could change how the Dolphins approach their 13th overall pick, but no matter the result it will be tough to convince me that Warren is the best choice and here is why.

I recently underlined a basic blueprint for the Miami Dolphins offseason (Miami Dolphins 2025 Offseason Blueprint: Key Areas to Address). I did not address the tight end position as the Miami Dolphins do have Jonnu Smith (pro bowler), and Julian Hill (whom many, including myself, are not fans of). But it’s not the room or the strength of the free agent market that makes me ignore Warren, it’s rather the numerous other holes in the roster, and the depth of this tight end class. While the tight end position could use improvement, it is not the Dolphins’ most pressing concern. Instead, Miami should focus on reinforcing the offensive line, securing depth in the secondary, and addressing other key weaknesses.

Top Tight End Prospects

1. Tyler Warren, Penn State
2. Colston Loveland, Michigan
3. Elijah Arroyo, Miami
4. Mason Taylor, LSU
5. Harold Fannin Jr., Bowling Green
6. Gunnar Helm, Texas
7. Terrance Ferguson, Oregon
8. Jack Briningstool, Clemson
9. Oronde Gadsden II, Syracuse

Warren is an intriguing prospect with significant upside, there are legitimate counterarguments to be made about whether he is truly the best option at pick 13. First and foremost, Jonnu Smith, while aging, remains a highly capable tight end. At 29 years old, Smith still possesses the athleticism and route-running ability to be a productive piece in Miami’s offense. Smith is coming off a record-breaking season in all fronts. Breaking the Dolphins receptions, yards, and touchdown records for tight ends (single season). The Dolphins also already have a scheme that favors speed and quick decision-making over a traditional tight end-centric attack. Additionally, if Miami is looking to address the position, they could find solid value in later rounds rather than spending premium draft capital.

Another key point to consider is the Dolphins’ roster needs elsewhere. The offensive line has been a consistent weakness, and with Tua Tagovailoa’s well-documented injury history, investing in protection for their franchise quarterback should take priority. A top-tier offensive lineman could immediately improve Miami’s pass protection and run game, making a bigger impact than a tight end. Moreover, an elite offensive line will unleash the full potential of Devon Achane and Jaylen Wright, Miami’s dynamic halfback duo. On top of the offensive line, the Dolphins need help in the secondary, particularly at safety, where depth has been a concern for years. Given these pressing needs, using a first-round pick on a tight end, even one as talented as Warren, might not be the most efficient use of resources.

McDaniel on the offensive line “I think we have a tangible opportunity to improve,” McDaniel said of the Dolphins’ offensive line. “That starts in free agency with a couple of guys that we have targeted. [We] think [we] can get a deal done with them, and that continues into the draft. I think it’s a very good time to have some need. It’s time for us to invest in that position and I’m excited to. That can come – I would expect it to surface itself in both free agency and the draft.”

Furthermore, this draft class is loaded with tight end talent, meaning Miami doesn’t necessarily need to use their top pick on one. Players like Cronde Gadsden II, (Syracuse), Elijah Arroyo (Miami), Mason Taylor (LSU), and Jack Briningstool (Clemson) all offer strong upside and could be available in the later rounds. With such a deep class, Miami could wait and still land a quality player at the position without sacrificing an opportunity to address more pressing concerns.

That said, there are arguments in favor of drafting Warren as well. He is an elite athlete with impressive size, hands, and blocking ability—traits that could make him a dangerous weapon in Miami’s already potent offense. Given the uncertainty around Smith’s longevity and Hill’s lack of development, Warren could be a long-term answer at the position. However, considering all factors, including Miami’s current roster construction and the depth of the tight end class, the Dolphins would be better served prioritizing other positions before addressing tight end in the first round.